The Michigan Chocolate Festival arrives in Grand Rapids on September 22, in the middle of the city’s popular ArtPrize. And so it only made sense to Chocolate Festival founder AJ Paschka to add a little fine art to the chocolate festivities.

But visitors shouldn’t expect mosaics of cocoa shavings or sculptures carved from chocolate slabs. Instead, festival organizers have commissioned the Grand Rapids Symphony Orchestra to create original music inspired by their experiences with varied chocolates. The compositions will be presented at a public concert the evening of September 22.

“We knew right away when we commissioned the work,” says AJ, “the concert could only be titled one thing: Bittersweet Symphony.”

Michigan Chocolate Festival Cacao Farms

From the lush fields of Honduras, Atucún’s cacao beans are nurtured through sustainable farming practices, ensuring rich and flavorful chocolate.

Photo by Courtesy of Jon Bailey

Breaking the Chocolate Mold

If composing original chocolate-inspired music seems a bit out of the ordinary, AJ likes the originality of the project. So do the craft chocolate makers who will participate in the 2024 Michigan Chocolate Festival, now in its second year.

After all, operating outside the mainstream is precisely how Michigan’s chocolate producers developed their reputation for excellence. Participants in this year’s festival include chocolatier and festival host Atucún from Grand Rapids, Mindo from Ann Arbor, Grocer’s Daughter of Empire, Chocolate Thunder of Kalamazoo, Dwaar Chocolate from Metro Detroit and Yellow Bird of Albion, among others.

Premium chocolatiers like Atucún, for whom AJ serves as sales and marketing manager, define fine chocolate as coming from high quality cacao beans, according to AJ. “It has nothing to do with fancy chocolate shapes and fancy fillings.” And fine chocolate makers start with a heavy focus on the origins of their fruit, beginning with the cacao tree itself. These producers use the terms “tree-to-bar” or “bean-to-bar” to describe their finished product.

Tree-to-bar chocolate makers work with local growers, identifying genetically pure and even rare varieties of cacao typically grown in a polyculture of compatible crops, plants and trees. Knowledgeable farmers are paid fair wages to propagate and care for the cacao trees before harvesting the beans at the peak of their ripeness.

Miguel Efren Elvir Maradíaga, who founded Atucún from his home base in Comayagua, Honduras, in 2017, takes pride in overseeing two hectares of cacao plantings nurtured sustainably and in the traditional ways of the indigenous peoples of Mesoamerica, where chocolate originated and has been produced for at least 4,000 years.

“I am not Willy Wonka,” says Maradíaga. “There is no magic here in Honduras, it’s a lot of hard work.” But the payoff in quality – both of the cacao and in the lives of his partnering farmers – makes the effort worthwhile.

Once the cacao beans have been carefully roasted and processed, either in-country or abroad, minimal amounts of sugar are added to sweeten the bar while maintaining its natural flavor profile. Maradíaga believes the resulting bars are more nutritious and tastier than other types of chocolate, and he is convinced that customers recognize the difference immediately.

Michigan Chocolate Festival Grociers Daughter Chocolate

Grocer’s Daughter Chocolate focuses on quality and sustainability with each thoughtfully crafted bar.

Photo by Courtesy of Jon Bailey

Becoming a Chocolate Connoisseur

Connor Tierney, owner of Chocolate Thunder in Kalamazoo, agrees. “I really look forward to the first impressions customers have when they try single origin chocolate,” he says, “Their eyes get wide, and they might let out a ‘whoa!’ Chocolate is like wine or coffee; it tastes different depending on where it's from and what cacao variety is grown.” But he says those nuances are lost when cocoa is subjected to high volume production processes or too many additives.

“Unlike wine or coffee, which we don't enjoy until we're adults, most of us have been eating chocolate in some form since childhood,” adds Jody Hayden, co-owner of Grocer’s Daughter Chocolate in Empire. “We have lots of preconceived notions about what chocolate is and how it might taste. However, those treats from our childhood are primarily made with sugar and very little cocoa.”

Bars available at the Michigan Chocolate Festival are crafted of cacao from Honduras, Colombia, Venezuela, Vietnam, India, and Uganda, among other locations. “The Chocolate Festival is the opportunity to explore a wide variety of cacao and chocolate from all over the world, and from different Michigan makers,” says Hayden.

When additional ingredients are added – coffee beans, nuts, dried fruits, milk or bourbon – they, too, should be locally sourced and handcrafted.

“Chocolate was considered the food of the gods by indigenous peoples,” says AJ Paschka. “And today it’s considered a superfood,” a product especially dense in nutrients and health-giving antioxidants. “Why would you want to add a lot of extra ingredients or fillers to that?”

Michigan Chocolate Festival Mindio Chocolate

In Ann Arbor, Mindo handcrafts bean-to-bar chocolate in small batches, using ethically sourced, pure, and flavorful ingredients.

Photo by Courtesy of Jon Bailey

Making of a Chocolate Festival

The 2024 Michigan Chocolate Festival will mark the second annual gathering of the state’s finest handcrafted chocolate makers. Scheduling the festival during ArtPrize, which takes place every fall in Grand Rapids, is expected to greatly increase the visibility of Michigan’s craft chocolatiers.

ArtPrize ranks as the world’s most well attended public art event, having drawn millions of people since the festival launched in 2009. ArtPrize 2024, which takes place between September 13-28, anticipates more than 950 artists from 42 U.S. states and 53 countries. More than 170 venues across downtown Grand Rapids will display artworks, marking the event’s highest participation since 2017.

The Michigan Chocolate Festival promises one more creative option for ArtPrize attendees. In addition to the Bittersweet Symphony, festivalgoers will be able to sample and purchase artisanal chocolate and ask questions of premium Michigan-based chocolatiers.

When the inaugural Michigan Chocolate Festival took place in Ypsilanti in September 2023, event planning was already well underway when two Michigan craft chocolate makers – Grand Rapids-based Atucún and Ann Arbor-based Mindo – had been awarded silver medals in the 2023 International Chocolate Awards’ Americas division. The competition included entrants from producers across the Caribbean, South America and North America.

Whether the Michigan Chocolate Festival moves to an alternate Michigan location or stays in Grand Rapids in 2025 remains to be seen. But one thing is certain: Michigan’s reputation as the home of high-quality, handcrafted chocolate is here to stay.

Story Resources:

Author: Amy Eckert

AJ Paschka, Michigan Chocolate Festival Organizer. 616-516-1344 aj@roastumber.com 

Connor Tierney, Owner Chocolate Thunder. 810-434-8131 connor@chocolatethunder.us 

Jody Hayden, Co-Owner Grocer’s Daughter. 231-342-0696 chocolate@grocersdaughter.com 

Miguel Efren Elvir Maradíaga, Founder Atucún Honduras. +504 9858-3535